Joan The Maid: The Battles (Rivette, 1994): ICA Cinema, 4pm
This screening is part of the Jacques Rivette season at the ICA. Full details here.
Roger Ebert website review:
Jacques Rivette’s 1994, two-part film on Joan of Arc is absolutely one of the director’s masterpieces. Why? Firstly, at least as far as its immediate accessibility is concerned, it contains one of the great performances by Sandrine Bonnaire as the French warrior-saint. This film exists in an entirely different context than Robert Bresson’s
“The Trial of Joan of Arc,” which made a cinema icon out of Florence
Delay. In the Bresson picture Joan is circumscribed as falsely accused,
tormented. Rivette’s film puts Joan in a variety of situations. She’s a
pious teenage girl, she’s a determined persuader/politician, she’s an
inspired leader whose mere presence compels men who mocked her before
meeting her to immediately acknowledge her saintliness. Bonnaire
inhabits all of these modes with breathtaking immediacy. Rivette was a critic before he was a
filmmaker, and others have observed that this film shows its
consciousness of prior major films about Joan — by Dreyer, by Preminger,
by Bresson — by minimizing repetition of the events depicted in those.
The two parts “The Battles” and “The Prisons” concentrate not only on
events not treated by other films, but on the spaces between the most
famous events of Joan’s life. Rivette applies a cinematic style that’s
both impassioned and elegantly simple and rational to Joan’s inner and
outer life, using long takes and brilliantly considered camera movements
throughout. While my experience of the truncated version
was still a profound one, finally seeing the uncut version made me a
little angry. In the shortened version, some of the excisions were, if
not excusable, at least coherent. Lifting one entire abortive attempted
journey to find the Dauphin makes some sense. Cutting off Joan’s
dictation of her famous Holy Week letter to the King of England, on the
other hand, now seems inexcusable. The director’s cut also features a device entirely removed from the
prior version. Here, supporting characters directly address the camera
to fill gaps in the narrative of explain their relationship to Joan and
their motivations for helping her. This takes the film out of the realm
of the pure period piece, to be sure. Yet Rivette’s execution of this device is so credible that the effect is less postmodern than it is magical realist — you will believe there were film cameras in the fifteenth century.
Glen Kenny
Here (and above) is the trailer.